Trump Mourns Passing of Supporter Shot During Butler Rally

President Donald Trump is mourning the death of James “Jim” Copenhaver, one of the rallygoers seriously wounded during the 2024 assassination attempt against Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania.
Copenhaver, 76, died Wednesday at Allegheny Health Network’s West Penn Hospital in Pittsburgh, according to the Allegheny County medical examiner and his family’s attorney.
Copenhaver had survived being shot twice during the July 13, 2024, attack at the Butler Farm Show grounds, suffering devastating injuries that required multiple surgeries and continued to affect him for more than two years.
Trump paid tribute to Copenhaver on Thursday, calling him a “true American Patriot” and describing his death as a “tremendous loss.”
“More than two years ago in Butler, Pennsylvania, a crazed gunman attempted to stifle our America First Movement,” Trump wrote on Truth Social. “Instead, Jim and so many other wonderful Patriots who love our Country, stood united in defense of our shared values of Freedom, Liberty, and Justice.”
Trump praised Copenhaver for the way he handled the difficult recovery that followed.

“Jim showed tremendous bravery, courageously continuing to FIGHT, FIGHT, FIGHT, and maintaining a positive spirit despite unimaginable hardships,” Trump wrote.
“His indelible legacy of love and devotion will forever endure. Our hearts and prayers are with the Copenhaver family, especially his incredible wife Marianne.”
Copenhaver was sitting in the bleachers behind Trump when 20-year-old Thomas Matthew Crooks opened fire from the roof of a nearby building.
Trump was struck in the right ear before Secret Service agents surrounded him and rushed him from the stage.
Three spectators were also struck. Former Buffalo Township fire chief Corey Comperatore, 50, was killed while shielding his family from the gunfire.
Copenhaver and fellow rally attendee David Dutch were seriously wounded. Dutch survived. Crooks was killed by a Secret Service counter-sniper.
Copenhaver was struck in his arm and abdomen. His injuries proved extensive.
According to a federal lawsuit he later filed, the gunfire caused injuries to his abdomen, colon and kidney, along with nerve damage and other medical problems.
He underwent multiple operations, including surgery involving his colon, and spent weeks recovering in the hospital and a rehabilitation facility.
Even after returning home, Copenhaver continued experiencing physical effects from the attack. He lost feeling in part of one leg and needed a cane to walk.
His lawsuit described the injuries as “debilitating, grievous, permanent and life altering.”
Copenhaver’s family said he faced the lengthy recovery with determination.
“Throughout that difficult time, James faced every challenge with the same strength and resolve that defined his life, and the kindness shown by so many brought great comfort to him and to those who love him,” attorney Joseph Feldman said on behalf of the family.
The family described Copenhaver as a devoted husband, father and grandfather who emphasized hard work, integrity and service to others. He was also a military veteran.
“James’s dedication to this great country was a defining part of his life,” the family said. “As a veteran, he proudly served our nation in the armed forces, and his love of country never wavered.”
Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday subsequently said Copenhaver had died from “complications stemming from those wounds.”
Copenhaver’s death comes months after he and his wife, Marianne, filed a lawsuit against the federal government over the security failures surrounding the assassination attempt.
Dutch and his wife filed a similar lawsuit.
The lawsuits accuse the Secret Service and Department of Homeland Security of negligence and contend that federal authorities failed to properly secure the AGR International complex adjacent to the rally site — including the building Crooks ultimately climbed before opening fire.
The litigation points to congressional investigations that identified numerous security breakdowns surrounding the rally.
A bipartisan House task force investigating the assassination attempt found significant problems with planning, communications and coordination among the Secret Service and state and local law enforcement agencies.
The attack produced one of the defining images of the 2024 presidential campaign.
Moments after being shot, Trump stood as Secret Service agents surrounded him, raised his fist and repeatedly shouted “Fight!” before being taken from the stage.
Copenhaver was fighting for his own life only yards away.
Video later recovered from Copenhaver’s cellphone also provided investigators with a chilling perspective on the attack. Footage recorded shortly before the shooting showed a figure later identified as Crooks moving across the roof from which he would fire.
Copenhaver’s death drew condolences beyond Trump.
House Republicans said he had “endured unimaginable hardship with strength and perseverance” and offered prayers to his family.
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, also expressed condolences while again condemning political violence.
Obama Defends Iran Nuclear Deal

Obama Defends Iran Nuclear Deal: “I Didn’t Have to Fire a Single Missile. I Engaged in Diplomacy.”
Former President Barack Obama has reignited the debate over America's Iran policy, arguing that diplomacy once restrained Tehran's nuclear ambitions without requiring American military action.
Speaking at a Democratic campaign rally in Detroit on October 24, Obama directly challenged President Donald Trump's justification for the ongoing conflict with Iran.
Obama questioned why military force had become necessary, arguing that an international nuclear agreement negotiated during his presidency had already placed significant restrictions on Iran's nuclear activities.
“Of course, Iran didn't have nuclear weapons,” Obama told the audience, before explaining how his administration had worked to limit the country's nuclear program.
“We had curbed their nuclear program because I put in place a deal that everybody acknowledged had kept them from getting nukes,” he continued.
He then delivered the central message of his criticism: “I didn't have to fire a missile. I engaged in diplomacy.”
The remarks referred to the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, commonly known as the Iran nuclear deal, reached in July 2015.
The agreement brought together Iran, the United States, Britain, France, Germany, Russia, China, and the European Union after years of difficult international negotiations.
Under its terms, Iran agreed to significantly reduce its uranium enrichment capacity and limit the amount of enriched uranium it could retain.
The agreement also restricted the number and types of centrifuges Iran could operate, while placing important facilities under enhanced international monitoring.
International inspectors were granted extensive access to declared nuclear facilities and parts of the supply chain supporting Iran's nuclear program.
One major objective was to extend the estimated time Iran would need to produce enough weapons-grade nuclear material from a few months to at least one year.
Supporters described the arrangement as a diplomatic achievement because it established measurable restrictions and inspection mechanisms without launching a military campaign.
However, the agreement was controversial from the beginning, with critics questioning its enforcement provisions, sunset clauses, and ability to address Iran's missile development and regional activities.
In May 2018, President Trump announced that the United States would withdraw from the agreement, describing it as inadequate and arguing that it failed to prevent Iran from pursuing nuclear ambitions.
The withdrawal became a major turning point in relations between Washington and Tehran, as the Trump administration restored sanctions and adopted a tougher pressure campaign.
Obama's Detroit speech revisited that decision, suggesting that abandoning the agreement had removed an important diplomatic mechanism for managing the nuclear dispute.
He also connected the current conflict to its economic consequences, warning that rising energy prices and military costs were affecting ordinary Americans.
His criticism reflected a broader Democratic argument that military escalation should not replace diplomatic negotiations when international agreements remain possible.
The Trump administration, by contrast, has argued that previous diplomatic arrangements failed to resolve the wider security threat posed by Iran.
The disagreement highlights two competing approaches to the same challenge: negotiated restrictions and international inspections versus military pressure and demands for broader concessions.
Whether diplomacy can again produce enforceable limits on Iran's nuclear activities remains uncertain, particularly as the conflict has complicated relations between Washington and Tehran.
For Obama, the central lesson of the 2015 agreement is that diplomacy can impose concrete restrictions without sending American missiles into another conflict.